| 2015 - Robert Rill, Jr. |
| 2014 - Steven E. Cokonougher |
| 2013 - Norman J. Mick |
| 2012 - James F. Easterling Jr. |
| 2011 - Kevin B. Todd |
| 2010 - Bradford Allen Goebel |
| 2009 - Terry W. Posey |
| 2008 - Charles Richard Murphy |
| 2007 - Ronald L. Winnet |
| 2006 - Michael A. Himes |
| 2005 - James M. Williamson |
| 2004 - Jim S. Deyo |
| 2003 - Steven John Krekus |
2002 - William Perry Mayberry Sr.
|
| 2001 - Thomas Eldon Reynolds |
| 2000 - Jack Louis Allen |
| 1999 - Ronald R. Rogers |
| 1998 - Douglas O. Brenneman |
| 1997 - Charles Michael Watson |
| 1996 - Thomas Harold Galyen |
| 1995 - Neil Martin Smalley |
| 1994 - James Edward Olmstead |
| 1993 - Thomas Darrell Zahler |
| 1992 - H. Ray Evans |
| 1991 - Paul Dean Gerber |
| 1990 - Charles K. Neff |
| 1989 - John W. McKahan |
| 1988 - David Lee Dresser |
| 1987 - George Orland Braatz |
| 1986 - Robert Earl See |
| 1985 - Hilmer Walter Neumann |
| 1984 - Richard Moore Wilson |
| 1983 - Charles Rolland Lattanner |
| 1982 - Vernon Eugene Musser |
| 1981 - Charles Baughman Moody |
| 1980 - Edgar Lee Miller |
| 1979 - Charles Albert Brigham Jr. |
| 1978 - Daniel Frederick Iceman |
| 1877 - Jerry Carmel Rasor |
| 1876 - Charles Sterling Ward |
| 1975 - Calvin Thomas Hubler |
| 1974 - Robert Dean Sager |
| 1973 - Royal Charles Scofield |
| 1972 - Dale Eugene Fox |
| 1971 - Fay Leoran Gullion |
| 1970 - Donald Murl Thomson |
| 1969 - Louis Charles Holzapfel |
| 1968 - Robert Alonzo Hinshaw |
| 1967 - Donald Emery Kretzinger |
| 1966 - Benjamin Rees Evans |
| 1965 - George Fred DeSilver |
| 1964 - Edgar Lewis Ott |
| 1963 - Colin Barker Montis |
| 1962 - Ralph Miller Francisco |
| 1961 - Daniel Calvin Jenkins |
| 1960 - Charles Herbert Strayer |
| 1959 - Charles K. Cunningham |
| 1958 - Chester Hodges |
| 1957 - Andrew John White Jr. |
| 1956 - John William Barkley |
| 1955 - Frank William Nicholas |
| 1954 - Edward William Kuns |
| 1953 - John Lloyd Guss |
| 1952 - Thomas A. Reber |
| 1951 - William McKinley Judd |
| 1950 - James Joseph Harbage |
| 1949 - William R. Pringle |
| 1948 - Levi Todd McKinney |
| 1947 - Raymond Andrews Younger |
| 1946 - William W. Carlton |
| 1945 - Ernest Frederick Schaefer |
| 1944 - David Barton Sharp |
| 1943 - Alpheus A. Stephens |
| 1942 - Harry Edgar Schramm |
| 1941 - Charles Bertram Hoffman |
| 1940 - Charles Ross Wilson |
| 1939 - Dillon Crist |
| 1938 - Harry Meyer |
| 1937 - Louis Bonte Blakemore |
| 1936 - John Phillip Perry |
| 1935 - Elmer Raymond Arn |
| 1934 - Carl Weir Ellenwood |
| 1933 - Samuel Herbert Squire |
| 1932 - Simeon Nash |
| 1931 - Harvey Francis Ake |
| 1930 - Harry Guy Gram |
| 1929 - James Walter Morgan |
| 1928 - Otto Hugo Hohly |
| 1927 - B. Frank Thomas |
| 1926 - Charles Laishley Minor |
| 1925 - Earle E. Stewart |
| 1924 - James B. Ruhl |
| 1923 - Campbell Marion Voorhees |
| 1922 - Harry Stevens Johnson |
| 1921 - Frank M. Ransbottom |
| 1920 - John Rouzer Flotron Sr. |
| 1919 - Matthew Smith |
| 1918 - Issac M. Kinsey Sr. |
| 1917 - Henry Marcellus Hagelbarger |
| 1916 - Joel Cave Clore |
| 1915 - Frank Henry Marquis |
| 1914 - George L. Marshall |
| 1913 - Charles J. Pretzman |
| 1912 - Edwin Stephen Griffiths |
| 1911 - Thomas Backus Guitteau |
| 1910 - Harry Seaman Kissell |
| 1909 - Benjamin Franklin Perry Jr. |
| 1908 - Charles Silser Hoskinson |
| 1907 - George Doddridge Copeland |
| 1906 - Horace A. Irvin |
| 1905 - Lewis Phillip Schaus |
| 1904 - Clifford Gilbert Ballou |
| 1903 - Orion P. Sperra |
| 1902 - William Alvin Belt |
| 1901 - Issac "Ike" Marshall Robinson |
| 1900 - Frank Sheldon Harmon |
| 1899 - Edwin Lewis Lybarger |
| 1898 - Edwin C. Gulliford |
| 1897 - Nelson Monroe Williams |
| 1896 - Barton Smith |
| 1895 - William Bromwell Melish |
| 1894 - Carroll F. Clapp |
| 1893 - Allen Andrews |
| 1892 - Allen Andrews |
| 1891 - Levi Crafton Goodale |
| 1890 - Levi Crafton Goodale |
| 1889 - Leander Burdick |
| 1888 - Leander Burdick |
| 1887 - Samuel Stacker Williams |
| 1886 - Samuel Stacker Williams |
| 1885 - Samuel Stacker Williams |
| 1884 - Joseph McKendree Goodspeed |
| 1883 - Joseph McKendree Goodspeed |
| 1882 - Charles Christian Kiefer |
| 1881 - Charles Christian Kiefer |
| 1880 - Reuben Compton Lemmon |
| 1779 - Reuben Compton Lemmon |
| 1778 - William Moore Cunningham |
| 1877 - William Moore Cunningham |
| 1876 - Charles Alexander Woodward |
| 1875 - Charles Alexander Woodward |
| 1874 - Asa H. Battin |
| 1873 - Asa H. Battin |
| 1872 - Asa H. Battin |
| 1871 - Alexander Huntington Newcomb |
| 1870 - Alexander Huntington Newcomb |
| 1869 - Alexander Huntington Newcomb |
| 1868 - Howard Matthews |
| 1867 - Howard Matthews |
| 1866 - Thomas Sparrow |
| 1865 - Thomas Sparrow |
| 1864 - Thomas Sparrow |
| 1863 - Thomas Sparrow |
| 1862 - George K. Rex |
| 1861 - George K. Rex |
| 1860 - Horace Morgan Stokes |
| 1859 - Horace Morgan Stokes |
| 1858 - Horace Morgan Stokes |
| 1857 - Horace Morgan Stokes |
| 1856 - Benjamin Finley Smith |
| 1855 - William Black Dodds |
| 1854 - William Black Dodds |
| 1853 - Lucius V. Bierce |
| 1852 - William Blackstone Hubbard |
| 1851 - William Blackstone Hubbard |
| 1950 - William Blackstone Hubbard |
| 1849 - Michael Z. Kreider |
| 1848 - Michael Z. Kreider |
| 1847 - Michael Z. Kreider |
| 1846 - William B. Thrall |
| 1845 - William B. Thrall |
| 1844 - William B. Thrall |
| 1843 - William B. Thrall |
| 1842 - William James Reese |
| 1841 - William James Reese |
| 1840 - William James Reese |
| 1839 - William James Reese |
| 1838 - William James Reese |
| 1837 - William James Reese |
| 1836 - William James Reese |
| 1835 - William James Reese |
| 1834 - William James Reese |
| 1833 - Timothy Baker |
| 1832 - Charles Anthony |
| 1831 - John Satterthwaite |
| 1830 - William Fielding |
| 1829 - John Snow |
| 1828 - Thomas Corwin |
| 1827 - John Milton Goodenow |
| 1826 - Samuel Wheeler |
| 1825 - William W. Irvin |
| 1824 - Charles R. Sherman |
| 1823 - John Snow |
| 1822 - John Snow |
| 1821 - John Snow |
| 1820 - John Snow |
| 1819 - John Snow |
| 1818 - Chester Griswold |
| 1817 - Henry Brush |
| 1816 - Henry Brush |
| 1815 - Henry Brush |
| 1814 - Henry Brush |
| 1813 - Henry Brush |
| 1812 - Lewis Cass |
| 1811 - Lewis Cass |
| 1810 - Lewis Cass |
| 1809 - Samuel Huntington |
| 1808 - Rufus Putnam |
